“America does not know what they’re doing.” (Lionel Ritchie) “What is the disconnect?” (Katy Perry) “Do not throw the remote at the TV, Ray!” (Ray) For the most part in this season’s first fan voting, the fans got it right. It’s the part that’s not the most part where my annual outrage lies. That said,... Continue Reading →

At last, we are at that point where the final fourteen survivors of the long Idol winnowing process are competing directly against each other. While I’ve had a list of favorites in mind, I was waiting for the clarity that I hoped this new, high-stakes test would bring. This week, I was fortunate enough to... Continue Reading →

Given the choice between watching real music stars or hoping-to-be music stars, America chose real over reality show and the American Country Music Awards sent Idol’s ratings to an all-time low Sunday night. ACM viewers did get to see ex-Idolist My Girl LaurenAlaina win the award for New Female Vocalist of the Year. And the word... Continue Reading →

There were so many good performances tonight that I think the evil genius producers planned to make the last week before voting get us excited about voting. The mean judge, i.e. me, gave out an unusual number of good grades. That said, it seemed like every Idolist had a hard luck story they were only... Continue Reading →

It’s Duets with Pop Stars! Here’s what Idol’s Missing Mean Judge is looking for. Who sounds like they belong up there as a peer? Who can hold their own and not be overshadowed by the presence or ability of the star? Who can seamlessly work together with their partner but also find the right spot(s)... Continue Reading →

Tonight, we saw the first half of the Top 24. Some were good enough to make me feel better that Thaddeus was not among them (e.g. Kay Kay). Some have the potential to be good (e.g. Jonny Brenns). And, frustratingly, a few are there to make for “good” TV (Catie Turner). The question, based on... Continue Reading →